May 2003, Issue #2

< Back to Readers Write
May 03

The Winterline Journal
is a publication of Farewell the Winterline featuring personal reminisces, funny & thoughtful stories by people who have lived in India, Pakistan, and the Far East as well as cultural articles, discussions and nostalgia.... with a few tasty recipes added for good measure.

Subscribe Below
to Our FREE
Winterline Journal
Newsletter

First Name
Last Name
Email Address
How Did You
Hear About Us?



Newsletter Staff:
Editor: Cynthia Brush

Graphics: Bill Grey

© Copyright 2003 Chipkali Creations

 

 

Readers respond with comments & vignettes

Cultural Connections:
You say Calcutta and I say Kolkata ...."
Submitted by L.Rebeiro - Toronto, Canada

* I too read the article about the change in this colourful City's name. Guess what? Now the founder of Calcutta is no longer the Founder.
Here's an interesting, short article about the historic ruling by Kolkata's High Court....

* * * * * * * * * * * *
Calcutta High Court today sought to rewrite the history of the
city - Cal HC Kolkata, May 16, 2003 (PTI)

Job Charnok was not Kolkata founder

The Calcutta High Court today accepted the expert committee report rejecting the notion that Kolkata was founded by Job Charnock and directed the concerned authorities to make changes in history books and other documents accordingly. A division bench comprising Chief Justice A K Mathur and Justice J K Biswas accepted the report by the five-member committee headed by eminent historian Nemai Sadhan Bose and directed the West Bengal government and others to take necessary steps in this regard.

The order came after Advocate General Balai Roy informed the court about acceptance of the contents of the expert committee report by the West Bengal government. The report, submitted before the court in November last year, contended that Kolkata grew into a city over a period of time and no particular date could be fixed as its date of birth or no one person can be said to be its founder. The judgement came on a PIL filed by the Sabarna Roy Choudhury family challenging the till date accepted notion that August 24, 1690 AD was the date of birth of Kolkata and Job Charnock was its founder.

After the submission of the expert committee report in November last year, the High Court had asked the state government and others to file objections on the report, if any. Apart from Bose the other members of the committee were Prof Barun De, former Director of the Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, and three other history professors, Sushil Choudhury, Pradip Sinha and Arun Kumar Dasgupta. The committee had been constituted by the High Court in April last year to look into the matter in detail and submit a report before the court to reach a final conclusion. The committee in its report said that while Indian zamindars like Ramakanta Majumdar, the Setts and the Basaks helped in the development of the city, so did Englishmen Job Charnock, Charles Eiyer and Goldsborough.
Noted lawyer Ajit Kumar Panja appeared on behalf of the
petitioners.


Cultural Connections:
Calcutta – again…CAISS again

Copyright 2003 Rita Wernli - Switzerland

I visit Calcutta every few years – my birthplace. This amazing city, pulsating with life, decaying with death, all in one. The sights and sounds – and smells. The people, the millions - so many in poverty so destitute as to be indescribable, others in comparative wealth, and a small minority with so much wealth as to be also indescribable. The heat as it goes towards summer, the mountains of refuse (the sight of humans, dogs and birds contesting in, searching for – perhaps something to eat, something to sell – who knows. Struggling to live somehow). The Calcutta daily symphony, always present, but varying with the time of day – the sounding of car horns. In other countries the use of car horns is strictly forbidden except for emergency. But since Calcutta lives in an eternal emergency, it is perfectly legitimate.

And now to CAISS – The Calcutta Anglo-Indian Service Society. A small society dedicated to helping Anglo-Indians in need. And there seem to be a great many. Calcutta always had the highest Anglo-Indian population in India, and probably still has. Britain’s withdrawal from India left them in a difficult position. Many left India – many remained. And so many live in great poverty today.

This small society tries to alleviate the suffering in so many ways. I saw John D’Cruze and Jessie Hiramanick distributing rations one Sunday morning. Not just handing out rations but talking, advising, consoling, admonishing – sorting out the sad stories as well as possible. After that, a visit to Tiljala……down winding lanes and climbing over open drains, visiting people living in various stages of poverty. I felt I did not want to pry into their personal lives to add to the complete lack of privacy they live in. But we seemed to be welcome. The social welfare includes a night shelter….The people in Tiljala have a roof, even a leaky one, over their heads. The night shelter takes in those who live, sleep and perhaps die on the streets. Calcutta has always had such people – but many years ago they did not include Anglo-Indians. I sometimes could not grasp what I was seeing. It hurts to see people in such dire destitution – it hurts that little bit more when they are your own people.

I also saw Lynette Deane and Leslie Ryan of the Education Panel at work. Like the welfare panel, they interviewed the children and their parents or grandparents with sympathy. There was a certain amount of firmness as well – there has to be – but one feels the underlying sympathy. There are so many stories to hear – the need for education has to be pounded into some heads. The difficulty of finding schools, and then the difficulty of getting the children into these schools. The usual picture of underprivileged people all over the world – women left alone with children, or grandparents left alone with children. The enormity of the job, being handled quietly and efficiently.

Philomena Eaton presiding over everything. She invited us to her birthday party! Quite hilarious. We enjoyed ourselves in the old-fashioned way. Coral Hines was there and we met up again. Coral, Derrick Hines’ widow. Derrick who gave so much of himself to CAISS. But Coral deserves thanks in her own right. She gave her support wherever it was needed.

I was happy to meet Leslie Pereira again and Renshaw Dennis. Leslie has the task of finding employment. Given the enormous competition, it must be a Herculean task. But it seems jobs are found. Renshaw is the Minister of Finance! A daunting job trying to make the money go round. I think that rounds up my CAISS report. My friend and her daughter were also most impressed with what they saw and heard. They both made donations and Anne’s small gifts for the children and some medicines for the night shelter were received with pleasure.

I would like to thank all of you for giving so much to making this society work – your time (spare time), your hard work, your dedication. Thank you.

Back to Readers Write - May '03